Choice Home Warranty Review

Written By Jeff Hindenach
Last updated March 27, 2020

Note: We receive a commission for purchases made through the links on this site. Our sponsors, however, do not influence our editorial content in any way.

Home Warranty
December 18, 2017

Simple. Thrifty. Living.

As a homeowner, you know how often houses demand minor to extensive repairs  and that regular homeowner’s insurance plans fail to assist with those services. Thankfully, you can overcome your worries about future repairs by acquiring protective coverage from the best home warranty companies like Choice Home Warranty. Browse through this comprehensive Choice Home Warranty review to learn more about this innovative protection plan for homeowners.

Best Home Warranty Companies

RankHome Warranty CompanyBest ForCostSTL Rating
1Select Home WarrantyOverall Service$299 to $499/year★★★★★
2Choice Home WarrantyTrusted Contractors$378 to $450/year★★★★
3American Home ShieldMost Popular$29.99 to $39.99/month★★★★
4HomeServe USAOptions$4/month (minimum)★★★

Best Home Warranty Companies

RankHome Warranty CompanySTL Rating
1Select Home Warranty★★★★★
2Choice Home Warranty★★★★
3American Home Shield★★★★
4HomeServe USA★★★

Choice Home Warranty Review

Choice Home Warranty website

Choice Home Warranty Review image
  • Price: The best home warranty service offers exceptional coverage at an affordable price, and that’s exactly what you get with Choice Home Warranty. You can pay for an entire year in one lump sum or make monthly payments for your coverage.
  • Plans: With both basic and full-coverage plan options, you can build a home warranty insurance plan that fits your needs.
  • Features: When you have a full-coverage plan, Choice Home Warranty covers everything from major systems and appliances to your garage door opener.
  • Customer service: Even the best home warranty service companies have negative reviews about customer service, but this is an area where Choice Home Warranty really shines. This company is available 24/7/365 for customer service calls and responds to quote requests almost as soon as you’ve filled out the form.

Select Home Warranty Review

Select Home Warranty Website

Select Home Warranty Review image
  • Price: Select Home Warranty offers its customers a choice of three types of home warranty plans, ranging from $299 to $499: Bronze Care, Gold Care and Platinum Care, not including the $60 service flat fee.
  • Plans: The Bronze Care plan offers coverage of basic appliances, like washer, dryer, refrigerator, dishwasher and range. The Gold Care plan protects household systems, like HVAC, water heater, plumbing and electrical. The Platinum Care plan covers everything from both home warranty plans, as well as a few extras like ceiling fans and plumbing stoppage.
  • Features: While each plan offers an overall range of what is covered, Select allows you to customize each plan to fit your exact needs. Select also doesn’t restrict service on appliance based on age and is one of the only home warranty services to consistently offer deals for its customers. Select also pre-screens all of the contractors that it works with so you know you are getting quality work.
  • Customer service: Select has the best customer service among home warranty companies. It won the 2017 “Best in Service” Award from Home Warranty Awards and customer service agents are available 24/7, every day of the year. Select also allows you to file claims easily either by phone, email or online form, and service is quick to respond.

American Home Shield Review

American Home Shield website

American Home Shield Review image
  • Price: Your price will depend on where you live and other factors, but prices start at $29.99 for coverage. When doing home warranty comparisons with American Home Shield, be prepared to enter your contact information in order to see pricing.
  • Plans: Like many other home warranty companies, American Home Shield offers coverage for appliances, systems or a combination. What makes it unique is the ability to build your own custom coverage solution.
  • Features: With 24-hour service guarantees and 24/7 repair reporting, you can get emergency repair services on your schedule.
  • Customer service: In addition to an always-on repair hotline and general customer service line, you can also use online chat if you have any questions.

Choice Home Warranty offers home warranties with comprehensive coverage for all your potentially costly home repairs, including appliance repairs and replacements. It expertly handles service calls from thousands of happy clients each month. Choice Home Warranty reviews show that this company only sends out the highest-rated, licensed, bonded and insured technicians to handle your repairs. Its coverage options range from basic system and appliance protection plans to optional arrangements, which may cover your septic system and extra appliances.

  • Choice Home Warranty USA partners its clients with dedicated representatives who follow each service call claim from start to finish.
  • It partners with local licensed, bonded and insured contractors to complete repair work quickly and completely with minimal downtime.
  • Its plans cover everything from structural renovations to appliance repairs, depending on the selected coverage level.
  • More than 8,000 happy customers have already left positive reviews for this innovative home warranty company.
  • Choice Home Warranty USA shows its dedication to quality service and support with top ratings and awards from Inc. 5000, Consumer Affairs and TrustPilot.

Each Choice Home Warranty review highlights its commitment to providing dedicated support for every client. You can get a free quote to determine if the home warranty coverage fits into your budget. Remember to tally up the cost of potential repairs within that time to compare expenses and make the best choice for the upkeep of your home.

Peace-of-Mind Protection: In Choice Home Warranty reviews, customers regularly tout the benefits of having total peace-of-mind protection after buying a home. Coverage for all unexpected home repairs allows you to maintain your home with confidence knowing you have complete support waiting in the wings.

Comprehensive Repair Techniques: Repair technicians partnered with this company never compromise on quality while completing the repairs in a timely manner. Techs always utilize industry best practices on small and large repair jobs for their clients.

Personalized Service Plans: Multiple service plans allow you to customize your level of coverage to match the needs of your home and budget. Choice Home Warranty reviews consistently show how well clients love the ability to customize their coverage levels.

Quality Customer Support: Customer support remains a top priority for this home warranty company. You will always receive personalized support from dedicated service professionals throughout the claim and repair process. There is also no service call fee. (Check out our HomeServe review to find out how it compares to Choice in regards to customer service.)

Price: $40/month and up

Guarantee: Parts and workmanship

What’s Covered: Electrical, Plumbing, Heating, Air Conditioning, Appliances, Water Heater, Garage Door Opener, Ductwork, Ceiling Fans and more.

Much like with other home warranty companies, with Choice Home Warranty, you can acquire complete support from skilled service professionals when you identify a need for home repairs. The coverage kicks in when your home experiences problems related to failing main systems, including heating and air conditioning, or broken appliances. The basic to optional coverage options allow you to customize your home warranties coverage levels to protect the systems and appliances you have in your own home.


The basic plan covers the main components and appliances found in most homes. Any problems with your heating, electrical and plumbing systems, along with most basic appliance repairs, are covered by this initial coverage level. Homeowners leave Choice Home Warranty reviews that highlight the basic plan as a great starting point for standard single-family homes.


The total plan adds coverage for air conditioning, clothes washers and dryers, and refrigerators. Even if you don’t expect to have problems with these items in the near future, it’s wise to obtain coverage well before problems occur. The total plan offers freedom from nearly all repairs your home might need in the near or distant future.


The optional coverage levels allow you to obtain protection for less common systems in your home. The optional level offers coverage for septic system components, pools and spas, sump pumps and extra appliances, including second refrigerators and stand-alone freezers. The optional plans even provide protection for specific types of roof leaks. With this level of coverage, you will never have to perform more than cleaning and maintenance on your own home while remaining assured that the rest of the upkeep will be performed by the best-rated professionals in your region.

The monthly premium for the basic service plan starts at $40 and increases with the amount of coverage added along the way. The first month is free for new customers to allow you to experience the incredible level of service and support offered through this home warranty company.

Choice Home Warranty reviews show that the plans cover parts and labor required for the completion of the identified repairs. If the systems are well-maintained and regularly cleaned, yet still fail to operate as expected, repair technicians will come out and perform the necessary restoration services. If the appliance continues to malfunction, the warranty may cover the replacement cost of that unit. At that point, you can simply buy a replacement appliance to restore the function of that system.

Easy Claim Filing: Choice Home Warranty reviews highlight the ease of the claims process. The claims department operates 24 hours a day, seven days a week to serve clients in need of support.

Prompt Service: Because Choice Home Warranty partners with local repair technicians, you will always receive immediate support with the upkeep of your home.

Personalized Service: The personalized service plans and coverage options for your home warranties are highlighted time and time again in Choice Home Warranty reviews. There is also no service call fee. This is a plus that other home warranty services, like Select Home Warranty, may not offer.

Excellent Technicians: The quality technicians are applauded for completing the job by the deadline while using the best repair techniques and top-notch building materials.

If you would rather leave time-consuming repairs to the professionals without worrying about potential expenses, then Choice Home Warranty might be the best choice for you. With this service plan, you can simply give the team a call to submit your claim and let the experts handle the rest.

You must commit to keeping your appliances and system components well-maintained and properly cleaned to qualify for coverage. Failure to do so could result in the denial of your claim. With the home warranty team on your side, however, keeping your home in great shape, year after year, will feel easier than ever. You must also cover the monthly fees to keep your coverage up-to-date and ready to go when it comes time to file a claim.

Choice Home Warranty reviews show that most clients remain satisfied with the quality service and support provided by this company. Many state that the peace of mind alone is well worth the price of the monthly premium. Even if you don’t end up needing to file a claim, you can rest easy knowing that all future problems are easily rectified with a single call to the claims line.

About the Author

Jeff Hindenach

Jeff Hindenach is the co-founder of Simple. Thrifty. Living. He graduated from Bowling Green State University with a Bachelor's Degree in Journalism. He has a long history of financial journalism, with a background writing for newspapers such as the San Jose Mercury News and San Francisco Examiner, as well as writing on personal finance for The Huffington Post, New York Times, Business Insider, CNBC, Newsday and The Street. He believes in giving readers the tools they need to get out of debt.

  • No comments yet. Be the first to get the conversation started. Here's some food for thought:

    Do you have any thoughts?

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *