Advertiser Disclosure: Many of the listings that appear on this website are from companies which we receive compensation. This compensation may impact how and where products appear on this site. The site does not review or include all companies or all available products.
Editorial Disclaimer: The editorial content on this page is not provided by any of the companies mentioned, and has not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of these entities. Opinions expressed here are author's alone.
User Generated Content Disclosure: Responses are not provided or commissioned by any of our advertisers. Responses have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of our advertisers. It is not any advertiser's responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.
Nearly everyone has a dream destination to which they’d love to travel — ideally for free. According to advertisements and well-known points gurus, travel credit cards can be a way to make this happen. Consider a few key factors, though, before you start packing your suitcase.
There is a multitude of airlines, and with that, even more airline credit cards. Each has a rewards schedule based on dollars spent, points or miles earned, and redemption value. They all are generally structured in the same way but it can be difficult to determine under which card your dollars spent go the farthest (almost literally). At Simple. Thrifty. Living., we’re focused on finding ways to make the most of your money, so we decided to dig into the numbers behind travel credit card rewards.
First, we rounded up the most common airlines based in the United States and selected each one’s most common consumer rewards credit card. Here are the cards we used, including their overall travel reward earnings:
We found the typical number of points/miles you’d need to redeem for the most common round trip flight across the US: Los Angeles, CA to New York, NY. We then calculated how much you’d have to spend on the credit card to earn such a flight using each card’s reward earnings schedule. With the JetBlue True Blue card, for example, you earn 3x points on JetBlue purchases and 2x points on money spent at restaurants and grocery stores, so we factored this into our calculations.*
It turns out that the budget airlines don’t always give you the best deal. When ranking the rewards credit cards based on how much you have to spend to earn a free cross-country, round-trip flight, Spirit Airlines landed at the top by a significant margin. You’d need to spend an estimated $37,500 to earn 75,000 miles to be able to cash in. The JetBlue True Blue card gives consumers the best value when looking at this metric, requiring them to spend less than half of what Spirit requires ($18,370). The rest of the credit cards landed somewhere between $18,000 and $30,000.
Many travel credit cards offer an early spending bonus when you spend a certain amount of money with your card within the first three months of having it. For example, the United Explorer card offers 40,000 bonus miles if you spend $2,000 in purchases in the first three months. That would be enough to earn you a free flight based on our study. Here’s a breakdown of the early spending bonuses each card offers:
Based on our study and the current offers from each credit card, you would be able to earn a free flight from United, Southwest, Alaska, and American Airlines based on the cards’ early spending bonuses.
After finding how much to spend to earn a free flight on each airline, we also wanted to put this in terms of time. To do so, we estimated how many months of credit card use it would take to spend the amount required to earn point for a flight. This is based on an estimate of consumers charging $2,500 to their card each month. The Spirit Airlines World Mastercard again ranked first for requiring 15.0 months (1 year and 3 months) on average. All other cards typically require less than a year, from the Hawaiian Airlines World Elite Mastercard at 11.9 months to the JetBlue True Blue card at only 7.3.
Finally, we decided to put these airline rewards in terms of big purchases that everyone makes. We represented each big purchase as a percentage of a free flight for each card. The largest purchases earn you the most on a flight, as you would expect. For example, purchasing an engagement ring (retailing on average online at $3,145) would earn you 10.7% of a rewards flight on average, whereas a television ($389) would only earn you 1.3%. The only exception is the purchase of an airline ticket, since you earn more miles/points per dollar on these for every airline credit card besides the Spirit Airline World Mastercard.
If you live near a certain airlines hub or find yourself flying the same airline over and over again, airline loyalty credit cards can be a great way to earn free flights. If you fly several different airlines or just want to earn more miles for your everyday purchases, you could try a general travel rewards credit card that rewards you with up to 2X the miles for everyday purchases. With these cards, instead of using miles to purchase a flight, you buy the flight first and use the miles to earn statement credits to pay for the flight, which eliminates any worry around limitations or blackout dates. Here are a few of the top general travel rewards credit cards:
Capital One Venture Rewards Credit Card
Chase Sapphire Preferred Card
Overall, we found that while the structure of rewards cards is largely the same across airlines, what you earn isn’t. Of course, there is a unique set of benefits for each card that may make the exact monetary differences unimportant to you. Alternatively, you may simply enjoy flying a specific airline, which may be enough of a reason to sign up for its associated travel credit card. Whichever one you choose, there is undeniable value in earning rewards for purchases you’re making anyway.
Advertising Disclaimer: Simple. Thrifty. Living. does receive compensation for some of the services that we recommend, although we only recommend services that we truly believe are the best.